Why did Philip Pullman call Narnia a "filthy lie"?
Playback speed
Did CS Lewis really get Susan so wrong? Philip Pullman's famous attack on The Chronicles of Narnia sparks a fascinating discussion as Christian writer Caleb Woodbridge and science-fiction critic Damien Walter unpack the infamous "problem of Susan", accusations of sexism and whether CS Lewis' stories are morally dangerous. This is the first part of a programme originally broadcast on the Unbelievable? podcast. Listen next week to hear part two of the conversation.
+ Support us here: https://www.premierunbelievable.com/geolink/donate
+ Subscribe to The CS Lewis podcast: https://www.premier.plus/cs-lewis-podcast
+ For more shows, free ebook and newsletter, visit our website: https://premierunbelievable.com/
Released on 17 Aug 2026
Coming up next
Philip Pullman vs CS Lewis: Do we need a true myth?
Is Christianity judgemental? Was Lewis too quick to judge his own characters? Can our imagination point us to the truth? From Star Wars and Doctor Who to His Dark Materials, Caleb Woodbridge and Damien Walter explore why myths continue to shape our i...
Why does Philip Pullman hate The Magician's Nephew?
Is it our fault when something bad happens? Can suffering ever be redeemed? In the final part of their discussion, Caleb Woodbridge and Damien Walter unpack Philp Pullman's critique of one of CS Lewis' most beloved Narnia stories. Along the way, they...
